11/16: When did *I* get to be the cynic?
Category: Bumbling | Posted by: Cads
There's been a large number of draft blog posts that I haven't posted and have deleted because they expired - this one isn't like that. I just read this article about the NSA (description here, and their website) potentially putting a backdoor into a cryptographical security standard. Firstly let me say this: And you didn't think it was going happen? Any organisation that is interested in Security is interested in Security that it can control. That's the case with ALL organisations - including PGP, CounterPane etc.
The LEVEL of control is what is important. PGP, CounterPane et al. are all about controlling access to sensitive data - NOT about giving themselves some way of seeing that sensitive data. They provide the controlling software but allow you and I to sit down and lock whatever it is that we want away. Think of them like locksmiths with no skeleton key. They provide you with a padlock and a key and you go lock away your beanie bear collection.
The NSA on the other hand wants to be in a position (as all government agencies do) of being able to look at what is locked away with their locks. It's like a locksmith with a skeleton key. The problem is that the types of people that they are selling the locks to are deemed to be criminals, and the NSA is the police. Of COURSE they are going to want to provide some way of looking at what the criminal fraternity is doing....
BUT, while the NSA is doing what the NSA is bound to do (after all, why would a normal person want to encrypt their data - only criminals and terrorists would want to do that1), the following statement from the article throws me a little:
This just boggles the mind for me. Surely this is just a cup and balls trick. "Look everybody," says the NSA, "there's a big hole over here!" all the while influencing the audience to choose one of the other cups. And this brings me to my point. When did I become so cynical that even the CTO of a cryptanalysis and cryptography seems näive? Is this an age thing? or is this latent paranoia.
OR have we become so used to the ways of openness that we forget what Vaudeville and Penn and Teller teach us about people being honest? Especially those with an ADMITTED hidden agenda.
*This of course is the NSA party line
The LEVEL of control is what is important. PGP, CounterPane et al. are all about controlling access to sensitive data - NOT about giving themselves some way of seeing that sensitive data. They provide the controlling software but allow you and I to sit down and lock whatever it is that we want away. Think of them like locksmiths with no skeleton key. They provide you with a padlock and a key and you go lock away your beanie bear collection.
The NSA on the other hand wants to be in a position (as all government agencies do) of being able to look at what is locked away with their locks. It's like a locksmith with a skeleton key. The problem is that the types of people that they are selling the locks to are deemed to be criminals, and the NSA is the police. Of COURSE they are going to want to provide some way of looking at what the criminal fraternity is doing....
BUT, while the NSA is doing what the NSA is bound to do (after all, why would a normal person want to encrypt their data - only criminals and terrorists would want to do that1), the following statement from the article throws me a little:
"I don't understand why the NSA was so insistent about including Dual_EC_DRBG in the standard. It makes no sense as a trap door: It's public, and rather obvious. It makes no sense from an engineering perspective: It's too slow for anyone to willingly use it. And it makes no sense from a backwards-compatibility perspective: Swapping one random-number generator for another is easy."
This just boggles the mind for me. Surely this is just a cup and balls trick. "Look everybody," says the NSA, "there's a big hole over here!" all the while influencing the audience to choose one of the other cups. And this brings me to my point. When did I become so cynical that even the CTO of a cryptanalysis and cryptography seems näive? Is this an age thing? or is this latent paranoia.
OR have we become so used to the ways of openness that we forget what Vaudeville and Penn and Teller teach us about people being honest? Especially those with an ADMITTED hidden agenda.
*This of course is the NSA party line
Comments
Brent wrote (12/02 04:51:23):
This evening I saw the film Elizabeth in part of which Mary Queen of Scots encryption scheme failed and her loyal guards seemed to be running a truly open source philosophy with her treasonous letters to the point where her head ended up in the big recycle bin and she got the delete written over it with the ultimate string of random characters.
In short, all hands have faced the problem Cads writes of with far more profundity than this economist could hope to muster, before. And what drives it is nothing new. The economist does recognise however, and our author here hints at it, the fact that the whole thing rests on the incentives of the lock er and the lock ee and those who seek to know their secrets.
So the good lesson in here is, think about the incentives at least as much as the coding!
coach outlet wrote (08/13 02:39:34):
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags outlet
http://www.coach-handbags-o... coach handbags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach factory outlet
http://www.coach-bags-outle... coach bags outlet
http://www.coach-handbags-o... coach handbags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... gucci outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach sunglasses
This article is written by zocy002 on 2010-8-13 on
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags
tn requin wrote (08/14 09:23:50):
It is great and comfortable using for running and walking, bottom plate produces a secure base for heel-to-toe transition, as a runner, the feeling of the Nike Air Max <a href="http://www.kkili.com">tn requin</a>is responsive cushioning. The transition wedge allows for a smooth ride in the heel to the Air-Sole unit found in the forefoot.(which helps reduce the risk of impact-related injuries). The highly resilient foam in Nike Air Max <a href="http://www.kkili.com">nike tn</a> columns is made of energy-efficient material that enhances durability and spring. About more details, look at the pictures <a href="http://www.kkili.com">requin tn</a>, please.
coach outlet wrote (08/15 22:17:03):
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet factory
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags on sale
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet sale
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach online outlet store
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... outlet
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... bags
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... outlet online
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... bags outlet
CoachHeels wrote (08/25 23:49:55):
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach bags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsout... gucci outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... New Coach Handbags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Shoulder Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Baby Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach HOBO Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Claire Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Sling Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Leather Handags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Maggie Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Patchwork Purse
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Carly Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Ergo Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Tote Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Luggage Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Cambrigge Hobo Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Barrette
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Bracelets
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Earrings
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Handbags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Backpacks
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Belt Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Briefcases
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Computer Cases
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Duffels
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Hobos
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Jolicoeur
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Messenger Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Shoulder Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Top Handles
ugg boots wrote (08/26 03:04:16):
i like<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg boots</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">uggs</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg australia</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg classic</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boots uk</a>,especlially like<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg classic tall</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">tall ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">short ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">uggs sale</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">buy ugg</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">discount ugg</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy uggs</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boots online</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">discount uggs</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy cheap ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">knitted ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boats australia</a> cheap<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boats</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy ugg site</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy discount ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">Ladies UGG Boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">UGG boots sale</a> ugg boats<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">UGG Classic Tall 5815 Boots</a> very much.there are several styles:<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5879</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5803</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5819</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5833</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5854</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5825</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5815</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5359</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5325</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5225</a> and they are the<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/2... ">2010 Hot Selling Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram</a>is the world leader in high performance rubber soles, targeted to the outdoor, work, recreation, fashion, repair and orthopedic markets.<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">five fingers</a> is the featured product of their. <a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram five fingers </a> are very famous all over of the world<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">five fingers vibram</a><a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram five</a>
ugg outlet wrote (09/02 09:32:12):
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg outlet
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg outlet boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org cheap ugg boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg sale
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Bailey Button Boots 5803
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Bailey Button Fancy Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Broome Boots 5511
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Classic Argyle Knit Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Classic Cardy Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Elegance Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Metallic Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Mini Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Short Boots 5825
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic tall Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Dakota Moccasin Slippers
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Elsey Boots 5596
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Gissella Boots 5593
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Kids Boots
http://www.ilovefashions.com Christian Louboutin shoes
http://www.ilovefashions.com yves saint laurent shoes
http://www.ilovefashions.com manolo blahnik</ahttp://www.ilovefashions.com cheap ugg boots
http://www.ilovefashions.com herve leger dress
http://www.ilovefashions.com bandage dresses
supra shoes online wrote (09/02 23:59:25):
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... cheap supra shoes
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra footwear for sale
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra shoes online
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra shoes
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Newest
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Skytop
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Skytop NS
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt outlet
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes on sale
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes online
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women VOI Shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women Shuguli GTX Shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women Lami Shoes
This evening I saw the film Elizabeth in part of which Mary Queen of Scots encryption scheme failed and her loyal guards seemed to be running a truly open source philosophy with her treasonous letters to the point where her head ended up in the big recycle bin and she got the delete written over it with the ultimate string of random characters.
In short, all hands have faced the problem Cads writes of with far more profundity than this economist could hope to muster, before. And what drives it is nothing new. The economist does recognise however, and our author here hints at it, the fact that the whole thing rests on the incentives of the lock er and the lock ee and those who seek to know their secrets.
So the good lesson in here is, think about the incentives at least as much as the coding!
coach outlet wrote (08/13 02:39:34):
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags outlet
http://www.coach-handbags-o... coach handbags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach factory outlet
http://www.coach-bags-outle... coach bags outlet
http://www.coach-handbags-o... coach handbags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... gucci outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach sunglasses
This article is written by zocy002 on 2010-8-13 on
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags
tn requin wrote (08/14 09:23:50):
It is great and comfortable using for running and walking, bottom plate produces a secure base for heel-to-toe transition, as a runner, the feeling of the Nike Air Max <a href="http://www.kkili.com">tn requin</a>is responsive cushioning. The transition wedge allows for a smooth ride in the heel to the Air-Sole unit found in the forefoot.(which helps reduce the risk of impact-related injuries). The highly resilient foam in Nike Air Max <a href="http://www.kkili.com">nike tn</a> columns is made of energy-efficient material that enhances durability and spring. About more details, look at the pictures <a href="http://www.kkili.com">requin tn</a>, please.
coach outlet wrote (08/15 22:17:03):
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet factory
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags on sale
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach bags outlet
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet store online
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach outlet online store
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach factory outlet sale
http://www.coachoutletfacto... coach online outlet store
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... outlet
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... bags
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... outlet online
http://www.gucci-outlet.us/... bags outlet
CoachHeels wrote (08/25 23:49:55):
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach factory outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... coach bags outlet
http://www.guccihandbagsout... gucci outlet
http://www.coachoutletmalls... New Coach Handbags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Shoulder Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Baby Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach HOBO Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Claire Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Sling Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Leather Handags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Maggie Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Patchwork Purse
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Carly Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Ergo Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Tote Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Luggage Bags
http://www.coachoutletmalls... Coach Cambrigge Hobo Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Barrette
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Bracelets
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Earrings
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Handbags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Backpacks
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Belt Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Briefcases
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Computer Cases
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Duffels
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Hobos
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Jolicoeur
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Messenger Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Shoulder Bags
http://www.guccihandbagsout... Gucci Top Handles
ugg boots wrote (08/26 03:04:16):
i like<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg boots</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">uggs</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg australia</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg classic</a>,<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boots uk</a>,especlially like<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">ugg classic tall</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">tall ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">short ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">uggs sale</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com ">buy ugg</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">discount ugg</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy uggs</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boots online</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">discount uggs</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy cheap ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">knitted ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boats australia</a> cheap<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg boats</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy ugg site</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">buy discount ugg boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">Ladies UGG Boots</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">UGG boots sale</a> ugg boats<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">UGG Classic Tall 5815 Boots</a> very much.there are several styles:<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5879</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5803</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5819</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5833</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5854</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5825</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5815</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5359</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5325</a><a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/u... ">ugg 5225</a> and they are the<a href="http://www.buyuggsite.com/2... ">2010 Hot Selling Boots</a>
<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram</a>is the world leader in high performance rubber soles, targeted to the outdoor, work, recreation, fashion, repair and orthopedic markets.<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">five fingers</a> is the featured product of their. <a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram five fingers </a> are very famous all over of the world<a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">five fingers vibram</a><a href="http://www.vibram5fs.com ">vibram five</a>
ugg outlet wrote (09/02 09:32:12):
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg outlet
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg outlet boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org cheap ugg boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org ugg sale
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Bailey Button Boots 5803
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Bailey Button Fancy Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Broome Boots 5511
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Classic Argyle Knit Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Classic Cardy Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Elegance Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Metallic Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Mini Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic Short Boots 5825
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Classic tall Boots
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Dakota Moccasin Slippers
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Elsey Boots 5596
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... Ugg Gissella Boots 5593
http://www.myuggoutlet.org/... UGG Kids Boots
http://www.ilovefashions.com Christian Louboutin shoes
http://www.ilovefashions.com yves saint laurent shoes
http://www.ilovefashions.com manolo blahnik</ahttp://www.ilovefashions.com cheap ugg boots
http://www.ilovefashions.com herve leger dress
http://www.ilovefashions.com bandage dresses
supra shoes online wrote (09/02 23:59:25):
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... cheap supra shoes
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra footwear for sale
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra shoes online
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... supra shoes
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Newest
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Skytop
http://www.cheapsuprashoesa... Supra Skytop NS
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt outlet
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes on sale
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... mbt shoes online
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women VOI Shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women Shuguli GTX Shoes
http://www.mbtshoesaleonlin... MBT Women Lami Shoes
Add Comment
Navigation
- Previous Item
- Next Item
- Today
- Archives
- All
- 40 Winks
- Bumbling
- Hums
- Smackerels
